Trading Desk Notes: Ultimate Pain Trade? Buy Bonds/Short Commodities!
2022.04.03 16:21
The Fed is finally ready to roll
After much hesitation, the Fed is signaling that it will raise interest rates aggressively over the next several months. Here’s what the market expects from the Fed (h/t to The Macrotourist):
Bloomberg Fed Fund Rates
The Chicago Mercantile Exchange futures market pricing of Fed funds through March 2023:
Chicago Mercantile Exchange Futures Market Pricing
After the sharp rise over the next 12 months, the market is pricing short-term interest rates to drift lower (tightening into a recession?).
Rate Cuts
Last year, in the face of sharply rising inflation, the Fed not only kept interest rates low but sustained their Quantitative Easing (QE) policies, buying hundreds of billions of dollars worth of bonds and mortgages. Their justification was that inflationary pressures were “and that ” inflation would be around 2%.
The market saw things differently and began to price in persistent and rising inflationary pressures. The market viewed the Fed as being the Fed was following, not leading the market.
This chart of the Treasury 2-year Note gives some perspective on how dramatically the market moved (before the Fed) since last fall. (Falling prices mean yields are rising.)
Treasury 2-Year Note Chart
Some analysts expect the Fed’s tightening (their attempt to ” inflation) will cause the economy to contract (a highly indebted economy can’t handle rising interest rates), and they will be guilty of tightening into a recession.
Other analysts see continuing high inflation, despite rising interest rates as governments increasingly embrace fiscal deficits. They believe that real interest rates will remain negative, and the market will demand “
From a consumer (voter) perspective, inflation creates a lower standard of living as their money has less purchasing power. Governments, seeking votes, may attempt to ameliorate this perception of a lower standard of living. For instance, they may cut some taxes, run large budget deficits, release crude oil from the strategic reserve, and suggest that to ensure the security of domestic supply, people will need to higher prices for (Do you remember President Jimmy Carter telling people to turn down the thermostat and put on a sweater when fuel prices soared?)
Global Inflation Rate
It seems highly likely that after 20 or 30 years of relatively benign inflation, we are into an era of higher inflation and supply shortages.
Real estate charts
USA home prices:
USA Home Prices
GS Housing Affordibility Index
Toronto House Prices
Soaring home prices and mortgage rates may produce “demand destruction” for new and existing homes. This chart of the Homebuilder’s ETF—SPDR® S&P Homebuilders ETF (NYSE:XHB)—is at >12-month lows.
XHB Homebuilder’s ETF Chart
The bond market: was Q1/22 the worst quarter ever?
Different analysts have described Q1/22 as the “worst ever” for the bond market. When I look at multi-decade charts of the long bond, I can’t entirely agree with that conclusion, but if I look at shorter-term bond charts (two to five-year maturity), I can agree.
Bond Quarterly Total Returns
I’ve seen other reports claiming that the classic 60/40 stock/bond portfolio had its worst quarterly performance in >40 years as stock and bond prices fell in Q1/22.
60/40 Stock/bond Portfolio – Quarterly Performance
The commodity market: Q1/22 was the best ever!
The leading commodity indices have been trending higher since the 20+ year low made in early 2020. The indices spiked dramatically higher in Q1/22 as the Russian invasion of Ukraine ignited supply concerns for food, energy, base metals and other commodities.
CRB Commodity Index Chart
Goldman Sachs Spot Index Weekly Chart
The ultimate “pain trade:” buy bonds/short commodities!
On the theory that market momentum takes markets too far in one direction and that “reversion to the mean” causes the price/sentiment “pendulum” to reverse course, is there an opportunity/reason to look at buying bonds and selling commodities—as an outright trade or as a “recession” hedge? Could a Fed “policy error” induce a “growth shock?”
Commodities have had a spectacular run with a possible blow-off top in March, and they have rolled over from a lower high. The bullish commodity “narrative” remains strong, and prices may well be much higher in the future, but if the indices drop through the March lows, they could fall further.
Goldman Sachs Spot Index Daily Chart
Bonds have been in the doghouse, and the is short bonds. Maybe the narrative is fully priced in. (See the Quotes section below for a discussion of )
Flows Into Global Fixed Income Funds
US 10-Yr Treasury Yield Chart
US 30-Yr Treasury Bonds Weekly Chart
A vicious circle: wild price action and shrinking liquidity
Wild price swings across equities, interest rates, commodities and some currencies in Q1/22 led to significantly reduced liquidity as traders backed away from risk as margin requirements skyrocketed. Volatility soared. Falling liquidity accelerated short-term price swings and meant that option positioning and capital flows had an outsized impact on prices.
Open interest in several futures markets fell to multi-year lows as wild price action and increased margin requirements caused traders to back away. For instance, open interest in the leading S&P 500 futures contract dropped to a 14 year low. Open interest in fossil fuel contracts, wheat and soy oil contracts, and silver and copper contracts fell to multi-year lows.
NYMEX CL vs Commercial Short Positions
My short term trading
I caught the first few days of the stock market rally off the mid-March lows—but took profits too soon. Last week, I started shorting the rally (with small positions and tight stops) and lost a little money. I thought that the rally was a bear market rally and would rollover.
This week, I continued with that idea, lost a little money early but benefitted from the 100+ point decline late in the week. I stayed short a small S&P position (with stops that will lock in a profit if the market rallies) into the weekend.
Emini S&P 500 Daily Chart
SPX – Puts
The Wednesday to Friday decline may have been only a brief correction to the rally that began mid-month, but if prices break decisively below 4500, that will harden my views that this has been a bear market rally.
I’ve been shorting the CAD around 80 cents, thinking that the spectacular YTD commodity rally could fade. I’ve lost a little money shorting the CAD but remain short into the weekend.
CAD Daily Chart
My P+L on realized trades is down ~0.75% this week, while unrealized gains total ~0.60%.
Transports flash a warning: Only one stock in the 20-stock Transports Index closed higher on Friday, and it was only up a fraction of 1%. The index closed Friday down ~7.3% below the 4-month highs made Wednesday.
DJ Transport Average Daily Chart
Thoughts on trading
My primary trading objective is to protect my capital. My experience tells me that I will have winning trades and losing trades, so it’s important to keep losses small to be ” to make future trades that might be winners. Staying alive and willing to trade is critical!!
I measure my risk tolerance in absolute dollars, not as a percentage of the item I’m trading. As a result, the huge price swings in many markets over the past few months drew me into shorter and shorter time frames and smaller-sized trades. For instance, it has not been unusual for the S&P (and many other markets) to move as much in an hour as it previously moved in a day.
Intraday trading seems to be more subject to chart patterns and random ” than swing trading. (Or it could be that all time frames have been subject to the recent poor liquidity, “risk and choppy price action.)
I’ve long maintained that traders need to find a way to trade that ” them. My ” seems to be a swing trading time frame of a few days to a few weeks, and that time frame appears to assign value to assessing market fundamentals, shifting sentiment and price action.
For most of my trading career, if I closed out a trade the same day I put it on, it was almost always a losing trade—I rarely initiated a trade to book a profit from it the same day. I’ve done some day-trading the past couple of months, and I’ve made some money doing that, but it required me to be constantly in front of my screens, and it is a different way of trading. I prefer the swing trading time frame over the day-trading time frame.
Years ago, I wondered if the path to making more money from trading would require me to increase my size substantially or to stay with my winning trades much longer. Or both! I decided to try staying with winning trades longer. In terms of the Rabbit or the Tortoise, I seem to be a Tortoise! I hate big losses—so I’m not willing to risk big losses to make big gains!
Quote of the week
Kevin Muir, the Macrotourist, Apr. 1, 2022
My comment: I read this quote in Kevin’s blog yesterday and laughed out loud! This is the trader’s perennial conundrum: ”
Dennis Gartman used to say that a trader’s job was to buy high and sell higher—that is, buy markets that are going up and sell them after they have gone up some more. (Sell markets that are going down and take profits after they have gone down further.) In other words, trade in line with the trend.
