Leading Indicators Continue to Suggest Imminent U.S. Recession
2023.06.06 04:19
Leading indicators of the US economy continue to signal an imminent recession, but coincident indicators are mixed, and some lagging indicators, most notably employment, are still showing strength. Therefore, it isn’t clear whether or not a recession has commenced. Also, high-profile parts of the stock market are muddying the water by trading as if a “soft landing” (no recession, but a large-enough inflation decline to cause the Fed to reverse course) were the most likely economic outcome over the next several months.
Turning to our favorite two leading indicators, first up, we have a chart showing that the Index (NOI) made its cycle low to date in January-2023 and returned to its cycle low in May-2023. As noted in previous TSI commentaries, at no time since 1970 has the ISM Manufacturing NOI been as low as it is today without the US economy being either in recession or about to enter a recession.
ISM New Orders Index
Next up is the yield curve, which remains inverted to an extreme. The extreme inversion tells us that monetary conditions have become tight enough to virtually guarantee an official recession. Still, the signal that a recession is imminent is a reversal of the yield curve from flattening/inverting to steepening.
A yield curve reversal from flattening/inverting to steepening has not happened yet. It’s possible that the rebound in the T-Note yield minus the T-Note yield (the ) from its March-2023 low is the start of a reversal. Still, the 10-year T-Note yield minus the T-Note yield (the 10y-3m spread), an equally important measure of the yield curve, just hit a new inversion extreme for the cycle. Daily charts of these interest rate spreads are displayed below.
10Y2Y Yield Curve Daily Chart
UST10Y3M Yield Curve Daily Chart
As explained in the past, the yield curve is driven by the monetary rate and tends to lag the monetary inflation rate at major turning points. Of particular relevance at this time, a reversal in the yield curve from flattening/inverting to steepening usually follows a major upward reversal in the monetary inflation rate. This relationship is illustrated by the monthly chart displayed below. The red line on this chart is the 10y-2y spread, and the blue line is the growth rate of US True Money Supply (TMS).
The monetary inflation rate has not yet reversed upward. This indicates that the monetary conditions for a yield curve reversal are not yet in place.
Note that for the monetary inflation rate to begin trending upward in the near future, a large amount of money probably will have to exit the Fed’s Reverse Repo facility. This could happen in response to the flood of new debt the Treasury will issue within the next few months.
US TMS YoY vs 10Y-2Y Spread Chart.
In conclusion, a US economic recession may have begun, but it’s now more likely that it won’t begin until the third quarter of this year.
