World

New York ivory ban for antiques dealers voided by US appeals court

2024.11.13 14:23

By Jonathan Stempel

NEW YORK (Reuters) – A federal appeals court on Wednesday declared unconstitutional a New York law that largely banned sales and in-store displays by antiques dealers of ivory and rhinoceros horns in the state.

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan sided with two trade groups that said the law signed by former Governor Andrew Cuomo violated antiques dealers’ First Amendment commercial speech rights.

The court called the law broader than necessary to promote New York’s substantial interest in stopping illegal ivory sales in the state, noting that it also covered goods that could be sold legally interstate or internationally.

In a joint opinion, Circuit Judges Pierre Leval and Myrna Perez said forbidding dealers from communicating “crucially important” information to lawful buyers about the quality and authenticity of ivory goods was an “excessive burden” on speech.

Starting in 1973, Congress largely banned ivory sales through the federal Endangered Species Act, but has provided exceptions for goods that were less than 50% ivory.

New York’s law went further, providing exceptions only for goods that were less than 20% ivory, and subjecting violators to fines of $3,000 and larger.

Sponsors said New York’s law was needed because elephant and rhinoceros populations were declining in Africa and Asia, with 96 elephants slaughtered each day.

Ivory comes from elephant tusks. Animal rights groups have estimated the global ivory trade at $23 billion annually.

New York’s Department of Environmental Conservation, which enforces the ivory law, had no immediate comment.

The law had been challenged by the Art and Antique Dealers League of America and the National Antique and Art Dealers Association of America.

Their lawyer Caleb Trotter, of the Pacific Legal Foundation, said the decision showed New York went too far in restricting the marketing of “lawful antiques and works of art.”

© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: Carved ivory is pictured before being placed into a crusher in Central Park in New York City, New York, U.S., August 3, 2017. REUTERS/Carlo Allegri/File Photo

Circuit Judge Richard Sullivan dissented from Wednesday’s decision, saying the Endangered Species Act preempted New York’s law altogether. He agreed that the speech restrictions were improper.

The case is Art and Antique Dealers League of America Inc et al v. Seggos et al, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 21-569.



Source link

Related Articles

Back to top button
bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC) $ 97,042.00 4.16%
ethereum
Ethereum (ETH) $ 3,139.74 0.57%
tether
Tether (USDT) $ 1.00 0.07%
solana
Solana (SOL) $ 242.09 1.86%
bnb
BNB (BNB) $ 612.54 0.36%
xrp
XRP (XRP) $ 1.12 2.43%
dogecoin
Dogecoin (DOGE) $ 0.385872 1.80%
usd-coin
USDC (USDC) $ 1.00 0.04%
staked-ether
Lido Staked Ether (STETH) $ 3,138.39 0.54%
cardano
Cardano (ADA) $ 0.78149 1.77%
tron
TRON (TRX) $ 0.198672 0.09%
shiba-inu
Shiba Inu (SHIB) $ 0.000024 1.80%
wrapped-bitcoin
Wrapped Bitcoin (WBTC) $ 96,659.90 4.09%
the-open-network
Toncoin (TON) $ 5.52 1.31%
avalanche-2
Avalanche (AVAX) $ 34.23 0.07%
wrapped-steth
Wrapped stETH (WSTETH) $ 3,712.07 0.92%
bitcoin-cash
Bitcoin Cash (BCH) $ 523.20 18.65%
sui
Sui (SUI) $ 3.53 7.09%
chainlink
Chainlink (LINK) $ 14.67 0.98%
weth
WETH (WETH) $ 3,135.91 0.58%
polkadot
Polkadot (DOT) $ 5.70 3.09%
pepe
Pepe (PEPE) $ 0.00002 4.99%
leo-token
LEO Token (LEO) $ 8.51 1.11%
stellar
Stellar (XLM) $ 0.239682 1.55%
litecoin
Litecoin (LTC) $ 89.97 4.76%
near
NEAR Protocol (NEAR) $ 5.50 2.63%
aptos
Aptos (APT) $ 11.62 3.44%
wrapped-eeth
Wrapped eETH (WEETH) $ 3,301.96 0.42%
uniswap
Uniswap (UNI) $ 8.86 3.05%
usds
USDS (USDS) $ 0.99602 0.66%
crypto-com-chain
Cronos (CRO) $ 0.175534 3.96%
hedera-hashgraph
Hedera (HBAR) $ 0.125457 1.26%
internet-computer
Internet Computer (ICP) $ 9.05 1.63%
ethereum-classic
Ethereum Classic (ETC) $ 26.77 3.68%
bonk
Bonk (BONK) $ 0.000052 7.95%
kaspa
Kaspa (KAS) $ 0.152802 5.22%
render-token
Render (RENDER) $ 7.40 8.90%
ethena-usde
Ethena USDe (USDE) $ 1.00 0.06%
bittensor
Bittensor (TAO) $ 481.61 2.39%
polygon-ecosystem-token
POL (ex-MATIC) (POL) $ 0.440623 2.30%
whitebit
WhiteBIT Coin (WBT) $ 24.13 0.92%
dai
Dai (DAI) $ 1.00 0.12%
mantra-dao
MANTRA (OM) $ 3.58 10.30%
fetch-ai
Artificial Superintelligence Alliance (FET) $ 1.23 5.22%
dogwifcoin
dogwifhat (WIF) $ 3.19 4.91%
monero
Monero (XMR) $ 160.51 0.55%
blockstack
Stacks (STX) $ 1.95 5.39%
arbitrum
Arbitrum (ARB) $ 0.70587 2.56%
filecoin
Filecoin (FIL) $ 4.48 2.49%
okb
OKB (OKB) $ 44.41 0.77%