Monsanto hit with $857 million verdict over PCBs in Washington state school
2023.12.18 17:29
© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: The logo of Monsanto is seen at the Monsanto factory in Peyrehorade, France, August 23, 2019. REUTERS/Stephane Mahe/File Photo
By Clark Mindock
(Reuters) -A jury in Washington state on Monday ordered Bayer (OTC:)’s Monsanto (NYSE:) to pay $857 million to former students and parent volunteers of a school northeast of Seattle who claimed that chemicals known as PCBs made by the company leaked from light fixtures and made them sick, according to an attorney for the plaintiffs.
The jury found the company liable for selling polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) used in the Sky Valley Education Center in Monroe, Washington. The verdict included $73 million in compensatory damages, and $784 million in punitive damages, according to Henry Jones, an attorney at the law firm Friedman Rubin, who represents the plaintiffs.
A statement from Monsanto called the award “constitutionally excessive” and said the company will move to have the verdict overturned or reduced.
The U.S. Supreme Court has said that punitive damages should generally be capped at nine times compensatory damages, because larger awards would violate defendants’ due process rights.
The verdict marks the latest trial loss for the company, which already faced $870 million in verdicts from alleged PCB exposure at the Sky Valley center in other cases.
The company is appealing those previous verdicts.
Monsanto said blood, air and other tests showed employees were not exposed to unsafe levels of PCBs at the school.
PCBs are chemicals once widely used to insulate electrical equipment and found in other common products like carbon copy paper, caulking, floor finish and paint. The U.S. government outlawed the chemicals in 1979 after discovering links to cancer.
Employees, students and others have claimed in numerous lawsuits against the company that exposure to PCBs at the Sky Valley center gave them cancer, thyroid conditions and other health problems.
The company said it stopped producing PCBs in 1977. It also said the school had been warned repeatedly since the 1990s that its light fixtures needed to be retrofitted, but that those warnings were ignored.
The various lawsuits name Monsanto spinoff Pharmacia as the defendant, though Monsanto is expected to be required to cover damages from verdicts due to legal agreements between the companies governing liabilities from historic chemicals production, according to attorneys for the plaintiffs and financial reports.
