Aegon shares drop on Spruce Point short position warning

On Monday, Aegon (NYSE:) Ltd. (NYSE: AEG, Euronext (EPA:): AGN) experienced a 3% decline in its stock value following a critical report from Spruce Point Capital, a management firm known for its focus on short-selling. The report raised concerns about Aegon’s primary distribution arm, World Financial Group (WFG), citing aggressive sales and recruitment tactics as well as competition from a new financial services platform, Global Financial Impact (GFI).

Spruce Point’s investigation into WFG’s practices, including a forensic review and field research, uncovered issues with the distribution arm’s business model. The report highlighted that WFG is a significant contributor to Aegon’s financial results, generating approximately $161 million in operating profit from distribution activities in 2023. This figure represents about 35% of the operating earnings in Aegon’s Americas segment, equating to roughly 25% of Aegon’s consolidated operating earnings.

The report also expressed concern over Aegon’s reliance on Indexed Universal Life (IUL) sales for growth, a product criticized for its complexity and fees. Further, Spruce Point suggested that a significant portion of WFG agents’ sales might be to themselves or to their own downline agents, a practice that skirts close to the Federal Trade Commission’s definition of a pyramid scheme. While WFG has publicly stated it is not a pyramid scheme, the report urges the company to adopt more conservative practices to avoid such allegations.

In addition to recruitment concerns, the report scrutinized WFG’s compensation brochure, which it claims uses outlier cases to describe potential earnings for agents, potentially misleading recruits with extravagant promises. The average WFG agent, according to Aegon’s data, produces just 0.4 sales per month, in contrast to the 5 personal sales per month suggested in the brochure. Spruce Point also noted that the average WFG agent earned about $6,500 in 2023, a figure that does not account for the costs incurred by recruits to become licensed agents, leading to a high dropout rate.

Spruce Point’s research estimates that recruitment is responsible for generating millions in profit for Aegon, with the top 25 recruiting teams in 2021 bringing in approximately 390,000 members and about $50 million in fees paid to WFG. The emphasis on recruiting within WFG’s system is such that advancement and earning bonuses are predominantly through recruitment efforts.

This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.